Document Type

Working Paper

Publication Date

2-20-2008

SSRN Discipline

Economics Research Network; Legal Scholarship Network; LSN Subject Matter eJournals

Abstract

This brief essay reports a study of citations to every article published in 1992 in thirteen leading law journals It uses citations as a proxy an admittedly poor one of article quality and then compares the citations across journals There are not surprisingly vast differences in number of citations per article While articles in the most elite journals receive more citations on average than the less elite but still highly regarded other journals studied some articles in the less elite journals are more heavily cited than many articles in even the most elite journals In keeping with studies in other disciplines and other citation studies of legal journals the results here suggest that we should we wary of judgments about quality based on place of publication We should also be wary of judgments about quality of scholarship based on number of citations and we should therefore continue to evaluate scholarship through close reads of it

Download

Share

COinS