Document Type

Working Paper

Publication Date

4-15-2020

SSRN Discipline

PSN Subject Matter eJournals; Medical Specialties eJournals; LSN Subject Matter eJournals; MedRN Subject Matter eJournals; CJRN Subject Matter eJournals; Legal Scholarship Network; Criminal Law & Procedure eJournals; Law School Research Papers - Legal Studies; Law & Society eJournals; Law & Society: Public Law eJournals; Criminal Justice Research Network; Political Science Network; Medical Research Network; Health Law eJournals; Political Economy - Development eJournals

Abstract

It is hard to overstate the impact of COVID19 When it comes to the criminal justice system the current COVID19 crisis has shone a light on preexisting flaws Long before the first confirmed case in Seattle or elsewhere America's jails and prisons were particularly susceptible to contagions exacerbated by problems from overcrowding to over policing to lack of reentry programs This Essay focuses on one aspect of the challenges the criminal justice system faces in light of COVID19 and beyond"”that of a pretrial detention system that falls more harshly on poor and minority defendants has swollen local jail populations and has incentivized pleas contributing in its own right to prison overcrowding brbrEven in the best of times the pretrial detention system is often punitive fraught with bias produces unnecessarily high rates of detention and carries a myriad of downstream consequences both for the accused and the community at large In the context of the COVID19 crisis this pretrial detention system faces an exacerbated challenge the health and safety of those in custody and those who staff US jails and prisons This new reality reveals that even during "ordinary times" the pretrial detention system fundamentally miscalculates public safety interests to the detriment of both detainees and the communities they leave behind Simply put current pretrial detention models fail to account for risks to defendants during periods of incarceration and pit defendants' interests against the very communities that depend on them The public health crisis of COVID19 demonstrates in very real terms the interconnected nature of a defendant's and the community's safety interests This connection is not unique to the current public health crisis however COVID19 brings to light the persistent reality that communities are often weakened not made safer by the removal of defendants during pretrial periods

Download

Share

COinS