Document Type

Working Paper

Publication Date

8-23-2013

SSRN Discipline

Legal Scholarship Network; Law School Research Papers - Legal Studies; LSN Subject Matter eJournals; Constitutional Law, Jurisprudence & Legal Philosophy eJournals; Humanities Network; Political Science Network

Abstract

Scholars and jurists have long assumed that when the executive branch declines to defend a federal statute Congress may intervene in federal court to defend the law When invalidating the Defense of Marriage Act for example no Justice challenged the authority of the House of Representatives to defend federal laws in at least some circumstances At the same time in recent litigation over the Fast and Furious gunrunning case the Department of Justice asserted that the House could not go to court to enforce a subpoena against the executive We seek to challenge both claims We argue that Congress has the constitutional power to enforce subpoenas but not defend federal statutes in court Congressional defense of federal statutes violates two constitutional norms First except in certain specified situations none of which are applicable here the Constitution prohibits Congress or one of its components from having any role in the implementation of federal law Second unilateral defense by the House or the Senate violates the constitutional norm of bicameralism The Constitution does not authorize either chamber to speak on behalf of "the Congress" much less the United States in defense of federal law By contrast the Constitution gives each chamber considerable power to investigate wrongdoing by the executive and to conduct litigation growing out of such investigations "• by for example enforcing subpoenas We believe that this limited congressional power to appear in court makes eminent sense The House and Senate counsel as currently constituted are poorly suited to defend their joint work product in court but are well situated to represent their respective institutions in other proceedings against the executive Furthermore this investigative power gives each chamber a powerful and often overlooked constitutional tool to do battle with the executive

Download

Share

COinS